en tant que musicien, ce que j'adore, c'est la surprise! le timbre de la voix de joni et cette compo du floyd ont berc é mon adolescence... et cela continue encore! chacun, chacune,peux avoir une idée, et la défendre: on aime, on aime pas. et cela ce respecte!! mais que l'on puisse manquer de respect à ces artistes, la, moi, je suis pas d'accord. Cela reviendrai à manquer de respect à l'humanité entière! pou r ma part: magnifique et surprenante version, pleine d'émotion, de force et de beauté.
MAN! She ruined it! ...( 6 months ago by cccs07)
MAN! She ruined it! I like The studio version with the REAL band Pink Floyd doing it!
I completely agree!( 6 months ago by cccs07)
I completely agree!
jyp25, je suis ...( 5 months ago by giinhhakha)
jyp25, je suis d'accord avec toi. belle chanson et cette version bien faite - je l'ai entendue à l'époque sans savoir que c'était Joni Mitchell. Et pour moi, ça c'est bien surprenant. j'adore la flute aussi. Je crois que c'est James Galway mais j'en suis pas sur.
She's not covering ...( 5 months ago by mrvideohound)
She's not covering it.She's performing it as part of Roger Waters's staging of "The Wall" in Berlin.The fact that the animation from the movie is seen throughout should have clued you in on that!
I have no problem ...( 5 months ago by tslupphaug)
I have no problem with people having their own personal opinion about a cover/performance, and I must admit I did not like this version of Goodbye Blue Sky the first time I heard it. But before you make up your final opinion, about this performance and others, ask yourself: If THIS had been the original, and the original had been the cover; Would you still have liked the "Pink Floyd - version" better? Fans often get too blinded by love to their band to accept original songs remade.
Shine on!
The perfect coming ...( 5 months ago by penfloyd)
The perfect coming together of rock/classical.
This music will be reverred in years to come just as we listen now to a Tchaikovsky or Beethoven...Overture
I never tire of Pink Floyds music....and this
concert never fails to move me...
Will we ever see the likes of it again?
フロイドの原曲よりもカッコいい！
と ...( 4 months ago by tabikurage)
フロイドの原曲よりもカッコいい！
と、僕は思う。
farsante( 4 months ago by huarachesk8)
farsante
Array( 4 months ago by LaVendogeinne)
C'est tr és possible que c'est Galway ou bein Paula.
butchered!( 3 months ago by JonnyLawrence)
butchered!
Array( 3 months ago by tafrescolei)
papel ón
It's to bad that ...( 3 months ago by Toonsville4396)
It's to bad that during some parts of the concert they had to lipsink during tecnical difficulties, oh well, still a damn great concert
Bad voice, that was ...( 2 months ago by cptkirk2007)
Bad voice, that was crap. :-(
Good Job!!!!( 2 months ago by EllieNelllie101)
Good Job!!!!
beautiful( 2 months ago by Deev101)
beautiful
I disagree. I like ...( 2 months ago by StrayGator)
I disagree. I like this better than the original in some ways.
I love covers like ...( 2 months ago by NeglectedField)
I love covers like this, that flesh it out a bit whilst retaining the emotional essence of the original.
interesting( 2 months ago by dolmadakia)
interesting
This whole concert ...( 2 months ago by jebogabog)
This whole concert in Berlin, right after the "Mauerfall" (after the Berlin-Wall was crushed) is an epic moment in human history. Absolutely breathtaking and overwhelming. If you let the music into your heart it will certainly touch your soul :-)
Joni Mitchell...big ...( 2 months ago by niltonyukina)
Joni Mitchell...big yellow taxi hehehe very tight!
Joni and Rodger are ...( 1 month ago by silversilver1975)
Joni and Rodger are both iconic figures,and this was an epic moment in human history for sure! Joni's voice is great,so powerful and yet so emotional.
Not even close to ...( 1 month ago by hop2171)
Not even close to the original, not even what i would call decent, she has the wrong voice for this song period
So do i. This is a ...( 2 days ago by ramsyghi)
So do i. This is a brilliant rendition and she was in this era, baby boomer. Bet it was fantastic to see in concert.
é mon adolescence... et cela continue encore! chacun, chacune,peux avoir une idée, et la défendre: on aime, on aime pas. et cela ce respecte!! mais que l'on puisse manquer de respect à ces artistes, la, moi, je suis pas d'accord. Cela reviendrai à manquer de respect à l'humanité entière! pou
r ma part: magnifique et surprenante version, pleine d'émotion, de force et de beauté.
à l'époque sans savoir que c'était Joni Mitchell. Et pour moi, ça c'est bien surprenant. j'adore la flute aussi. Je crois que c'est James Galway mais j'en suis pas sur.
This music will be reverred in years to come just as we listen now to a Tchaikovsky or Beethoven...Overture
I never tire of Pink Floyds music....and this
concert never fails to move me...
Will we ever see the likes of it again?
és possible que c'est Galway ou bein Paula.
ón