No, it isn't. If you look at Yoshi's Island (which you are ignoring), then you would know that Shy Guys existed in Mario's past, meaning that none of the SMB2 enemies came from Mario's dreams, and were actually influenced by his past. Even Wart could have been influenced by Yoshi's Island and Mario's past (Prince Froggy in world 3 could have influenced Mario dreams).
Which is why it's ...( 9 months ago by adamrulz)
Which is why it's retcon. Super Mario Bros. 2 came out years before Yoshi's Island. Irrelevant. Mario's dream could logically be a mix of real and imaginary things, as his friends are in it, but that doesn't mean Birdo was pre-existant, as he's not referenced earlier in the timeline at all.
Yes, but that still ...( 9 months ago by VaderNES)
Yes, but that still doesn't mean she just popped-out of Mario's dream. She had to have existed before then. And Birdos are a species, meaning that the Birdo in the spinoffs is most likely not one from SMB2.
It's a fucking ...( 9 months ago by adamrulz)
It's a fucking video game. He very well could have popped out of the world of dreams just like Goombas exist outside of the Mushroom Kingdom and Yoshi exists outside of Dinosaur Land.
The Mushroom ...( 9 months ago by VaderNES)
The Mushroom Kingdom is only a country in the Mushroom World, and Yoshi's Island is a part of Dinosaur Land, which is another country in the Mushroom world. She did not pop out of Mario's dreams, because that is still impossible. And you are still not explaining that every game after SMB2 says she is female. You lose, because you are adumbass who ignores logic.
Where the fuck did ...( 9 months ago by adamrulz)
Where the fuck did you learn this shit?
And please stop saying "she". You remind of some kind of trannie sympathist and I keep getting confused about what you're talking about.
And why do I have to explain attempted retcon? I don't actually recall games specifically stating he is now female. Though I understand it's mentioned in one of the more recent retcon attempts for the most part it's simply goes unsaid.
I will not stop ...( 9 months ago by VaderNES)
I will not stop correctly calling her "she". She is not a transvestite, and you still fail. She is female, and I rest my case. Don't be a dumbass, and actually look at those manuals.
LOL birdo is a male ...( 9 months ago by Cresantstar)
LOL birdo is a male in japan and he doesnt shoot eggs out of his vagina cause he doesnt have one
so he shoots them out of his mouth LOL
LOL birdo is a male ...( 9 months ago by Cresantstar)
LOL birdo is a male in japan and he doesnt shoot eggs out of his vagina cause he doesnt have one
so he shoots them out of his mouth LOL
LOL birdo is a male ...( 9 months ago by Cresantstar)
LOL birdo is a male in japan and he doesnt shoot eggs out of his vagina cause he doesnt have one
so he shoots them out of his mouth LOL
You have no factual ...( 9 months ago by VaderNES)
You have no factual backing to this. I have factual backing to prove my point.
Oi. Imagine ...( 9 months ago by adamrulz)
Oi. Imagine shooting that out of your penis...
i would if i had one( 9 months ago by Cresantstar)
i would if i had one
lol hahaha 1st ...( 6 months ago by pokemonblaster888)
lol hahaha 1st seconds lol
the female birdo ...( 5 months ago by katten838)
the female birdo has a penis in her face
The us version made ...( 5 months ago by katten838)
The us version made him a female because it was to scandalous, in japan hes still male
Bullshit. You ...( 5 months ago by VaderNES)
Bullshit. You ignore my factual backing (Birdo was only male in Mario's dreams).
I'm fighting it ...( 5 months ago by VaderNES)
I'm fighting it here, too. And in Japan, she was originallly female (in Doki Doki Panic).
Wow are we still ...( 5 months ago by adamrulz)
Wow are we still doing this? Birdo has been in so many games and has had a penis in all of them. It's simple.
that is one patetic ...( 5 months ago by koopa1248)
that is one patetic birdo suit.
true!( 5 months ago by koopa1248)
true!
you make birdo look ...( 5 months ago by koopa1248)
you make birdo look like she has a penis.
notice birdo never ...( 5 months ago by koopa1248)
so he shoots them out of his mouth LOL
so he shoots them out of his mouth LOL
so he shoots them out of his mouth LOL