I respect your opinion, now here's mine: Its pretty ignorant saying that Oasis did nothing original. They have a very unique sound. Everyone musician has influences and it shows in their music. Even the Beatles reproduced what black musicians already had in the US. Noel Gallagher took his inspirations from other artists and made something out of it as ALL other musicians did. Lyrically, Noel Gallagher is the one of the finest songwriters of his time. ALL artists have high and low points.
My comments were ...( 2 weeks ago by gretgael1)
My comments were not ignorant! Other musicians shape their own sound from their influences but i feel Noel didn't do this, he just blatantly stole from his influences,now that's just my opinion, just because it differs from yours don't mean i'm ignorant,just a clash of opinions!
As for lyrically Noel being one of the finest songwriters of all time i just can't agree with that! Which songs of his are you referring to? Dylan, Lennon, morrissey, weller, bono etc...now they're great songwriters!
best singer and ...( 2 weeks ago by samnalex12345)
best singer and best song
Psul Weller sama is ...( 2 weeks ago by sheepandgreen)
Psul Weller sama is the only man that I've ever loved in my life. He is my hero.
Big love from Tokyo
I'm born and bred ...( 1 week ago by GunnerGraham)
I'm born and bred Manchester(Salford),and love Noel,but,Weller is superior.A true pro.
lost for words( 1 week ago by davies545)
lost for words
because it has been ...( 1 week ago by chipfire)
because it has been ruined by galagher?
third class( 1 week ago by chipfire)
third class
Hey this is good, ...( 1 week ago by KingUser2008)
Hey this is good, But I prefer the original Jam...anyway well done.
how did he ruin it? ...( 1 week ago by paranoid711)
how did he ruin it?
they both rock equally
no way. weller ...( 1 week ago by GonzoFilmer)
no way. weller shits on gallagher
just by being there ...( 1 week ago by chipfire)
just by being there - he has no place on stage with Weller
Both these guys are ...( 1 week ago by warriorprince1010)
Both these guys are brilliant.
Quit being stupid.
Lets be honest, its ...( 1 week ago by downtwothenleft)
Lets be honest, its pretty basic stuff. Hardly a classic. I mean if I can play this song on my acoustic and make it sound exactly like the original, its not exactly Steely dan type chords is it?
watching this video ...( 6 days ago by viomartyr)
watching this video makes me feel like i'm watching a music lesson where paul is the teacher and noel is the student... there are not too many people noel looks up to but PW is definitely one of them. brilliant performance by both musicians ;P
Tunage...( 6 days ago by cavansputnik)
Tunage...
yea, agree with ...( 6 days ago by owenthepenguin)
yea, agree with that nice soundin fella wariorprince1010 , if your a stupid twunt (see what i did, twat + cunt, one day that'll be an internet sensation) then you'll talk shit about this, this is a great version, with two quality musicians, whoom i would love to meet and see live, tho paul weller is a complete legend, doesn't mean noel gallager shouldnt be there, it would be like the arctic monkeys play with the beatles which i would love to see. the new young boys and the complete legends, WOOP
that was the ...( 6 days ago by owenthepenguin)
that was the longest i could have written, now im happy
For all of you ...( 6 days ago by OasisKid99)
For all of you trashing Noel Gallagher, do yourselves a favor and watch Slide Away Live In Melbourne, it's on youtube. Do it, then think about what you've said.
You're a bit of a ...( 4 days ago by Dazzypig)
You're a bit of a twat aren't you? And let's be honest you can't like music that much if you make comments like that about good music "not exactly steely dan chords" why watch the video then? What did you think it was going to be? Or maybe you've just, in your wealth of knowledge on complex "steely dan chord" music, never heard of The Jam...
My comments ...( 3 days ago by downtwothenleft)
My comments regarding Weller are based on a varied musical knowledge spanning 30 years and being in several bands. What is yours based on? Sitting in your bedroom listening to the Jam on your 3 bob cd player, smokin weed? I,ve probably owned more Jam stuff in my time than you. So dont try to lecture me, you tit, when it comes to music!
noel gallagher is ...( 3 days ago by bigdaveupload)
noel gallagher is the man
Varied musical ...( 2 days ago by Dazzypig)
Varied musical knowledge? you stated that it wasn't technical, I must've forgot that this video was filmed during Weller's dip into guitar virtuoso. I'm a regularly performing musician as well thank you very much, and I don't appreciate the insinuation that I do drugs. Don't project you own flaws onto other people.
As for lyrically Noel being one of the finest songwriters of all time i just can't agree with that! Which songs of his are you referring to? Dylan, Lennon, morrissey, weller, bono etc...now they're great songwriters!
Big love from Tokyo