Gilmour is an all time great guitar player, awesome singer, but I don't know. I feel like the post Waters era is so weak and wimpy compared to what came before. Waters' anger and the questions he asked were so relevant and real people can identify. What is Gilmour even talking about, though? Without Waters it isn't Pink Floyd, period. People might say the same thing about Barrett, but that's a different argument.
I have to agree. ...( 1 week ago by piscator3444)
I have to agree. Waters provided that edge. Still, you have to appreciate Gilmour's ability to reproduce a song to the note -- every tiome he plays it.
wow...i would die ...( 1 week ago by ajg2012)
wow...i would die and NGAF at Pink Floyd concert if I could afford the tickets...Mom can you buy me some PF tickets.
I'm in love with ...( 1 week ago by keesjansma)
I'm in love with this song as well as with the background singer (the one on the righ), what a woman :o
Thats why when ...( 1 week ago by phailandaids)
Thats why when Walters left Pink Floyd he struggled to get a minimal audience while PF were filling arenas?....Walters was good but too arrogant, he thought PF was nothing without him and he got all butthurt when they proved him wrong.
I will give you one thing tho...Walters music was more powerful but Gilmours is every bit as meaningful and deep
its roger waters( 1 week ago by bmoredragon01)
its roger waters
I agree with the ...( 1 week ago by ladymindful)
I agree with the comment the Waters was too arrogant. He did have some edgy songwriting but David Gilmour is the better singer, the better guitar player and absolutely drop dead gorgeous. PF rocks w/Gilmour. Love you!!
David Gilmour is ...( 1 week ago by Alexroy666)
David Gilmour is simply a genius
here's my 5 all ...( 1 week ago by kewlpnay126)
here's my 5 all time bands/group.beatles,pink floyd,led zeppelin,the who,rolling stones.give me yours.
In no particular ...( 1 week ago by newrulz2005)
In no particular order:
Moody Blues
Pink Floyd
The Beatles
Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young (in all their bands)
Jethro Tull
This is a truly ...( 1 week ago by moramayorga)
This is a truly song of freedom simply genius
Good!( 1 week ago by matheuszanella)
Good!
The guitar has a ...( 1 week ago by Abebe345)
The guitar has a voice.
Boy, you ain't ...( 1 week ago by SNIPER8542)
Boy, you ain't kiddin'
Whew!
You got that right( 1 week ago by SNIPER8542)
You got that right
From 4:50 on, this ...( 1 week ago by georgemasiello)
From 4:50 on, this song gives me goose bumps...sort of a haunting sound! In my top-10 of all time.
Albert Einstein, ...( 5 days ago by sophieapril)
Albert Einstein, Alex Fregerson, Leonardo da Vinci, Charles Darwin, Beethoven , Shakespere they were all genius
DAVID GILMORE is a GOD
AMEN! praise David!( 5 days ago by denny91673)
AMEN! praise David!
One of the few ...( 5 days ago by Abebe345)
One of the few songs i liked upon initial hearing. I saw the concert that year in Versailles.
gilmore rules ,my ...( 3 days ago by tref101)
gilmore rules ,my best axeman,the bomb!
David Guilmour has ...( 3 days ago by a9b3a1)
David Guilmour has a girt of God, he sings with his heart; Pink Floyd I wish you guys very long life, God bless you guys.
best concert ever( 2 days ago by Harvin87)
best concert ever
timeless( 2 days ago by sbbane)
timeless
One of their very ...( 11 hours ago by lilacgirlie)
One of their very best ever! Love this, could listen to it forever!
Whew!
DAVID GILMORE is a GOD